one of my good friends is in tatters over her 8-year-old relationship with her bf. she's my colleague actually. i'm not usually close to girls, but this one is particularly great to have around. anyway, she's really depressed and she says that she has never been this depressed in her life. she now understands how people feel when they say that they are depressed. i told her that after amos broke up with one of his exes in uni, he got really depressed too. after the whole experience, he became an atheist. i jokingly say that i'll lure her to the "dark" side (the light side really, haha).
i see two main solutions whenever someone faces a huge tragedy in their lives. i mean, really huge, life-changing sort of tragedy. these are the assumptions:
- you feel that you are not in control of your life
- there is a lot of pain
option 1: you are helpless. you cannot function. you start to think it's a test of faith. you start praying and reading the bible. every verse seem to speak to you. talking to god comforts you. god says that everything will be alright and you believe him. only god can help you. you draw strength from god. soon the crisis resolves and you praise god, reaffirming your faith and telling everyone that god was there for you.
option 2: you are helpless. you cannot function. you start to realise that god is not listening. if he loves you, why would he cause you so much pain? did he require suffering in order for people to love him? you start to question your faith and you realise that there is no god, only yourself and the pain. only you can help yourself. at this point, you draw strength from yourself and people around you to face the problem. soon the crisis resolves and you become an atheist.
=====
of course problems are not that simplistic. some people don't choose option 1 or 2, and commit suicide, develop mental problems, kill somebody etc. and it's difficult to say what choices you will make until you're in that amount of pain. i like to think that i'm rational and option 2 would be it. but who knows? i may not be strong enough and only the belief that something greater can help me is so appealing. after all, tolkien said, there are, indeed, no atheists in foxholes. but then, there are no atheist suicide bombers either.
choose your life, there is no right answer really. christians will tell you that jesus is the only answer. they are so so sure. but i say, that there is more than one option.
"We exist on a spectrum that goes from the unconscious to the fully conscious, and once we've left unconscious grace behind we can't go back, we can only go on - through life, through education, through suffering, through experience to the thing we come to call wisdom, which is right at the other end of the spectrum." - Philip Pullman